Comments on "Which is the Quantum Decay Law of Relativistic Particles?"

Abstract

Results presented in a recent paper "Which is the Quantum Decay Law of Relativistic particles?", arXiv: 1412.3346v2 [quant--ph]], are analyzed. We show that approximations used therein to derive the main final formula for the survival probability of finding a moving unstable particle to be undecayed at time $t$ force this particle to almost stop moving, that is that, in fact, the derived formula is approximately valid only for $\gamma \cong 1$, where $\gamma =1/\sqrt{1-{\beta }^2}$ and $\beta =v/c$, or in other words, for the velocity $v\simeq 0$.

Comments: 8 pages, additional analysis and comments added