Comparative variational studies of $0^{+}$ states in three-$\alpha$ models

Abstract

Three variational approaches, the hyperspherical-harmonics, Gaussian-basis and Lagrange-mesh methods involving different coordinate systems, are compared in studies of $0^{+}$ bound-state energies in 3$\alpha$ models. Calculations are performed with different versions of the shallow Ali-Bodmer potential (with and without Coulomb) and with the deep Buck-Friedrich-Wheatley potential. All three methods yield very accurate energies. Their advantages and drawbacks are evaluated. The implications of the disagreement between the obtained results and the experimental ${}^{12}$C energies in $3\alpha$ models with Coulomb interaction are discussed.