Comment on "Nuclear Excitation by Free Muon Capture"

Abstract

In the paper [1] the process of free muon capture with simultaneous excitation of a nuclear isomer has been suggested, claiming that ``the effect can be detectable for selected isotopes". Here, we argue that this claim can not be confirmed. Briefly, the process is far from the dominant mechanism for nuclear excitation; it excites high energy nuclear levels that will not generally decay to the isomer; the proposal assumes all incident muons will fulfil energy criteria, ignoring dominant capture paths; and nuclei excited by muons will have a shortened lifetime due to muonic capture.