PaperPanorama

arXiv:1705.05538·v1·Nuclear Theory

Comment on "Three-dimensional study of the six-body bound-state for the case of effective three-body configuration model" [Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 25, 9 (2016) 1650072]

M. R. Hadizadeh · M. Radin · S. Bayegan

Abstract

The authors argue that the calculated He binding energies by the solution of the coupled Faddeev-Yakubovsky integral equation in a Three-dimensional scheme reported by E. Ahmadi Pouya and A. A. Rajabi [Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 25, 9 (2016) 1650072] are incorrect. The formalism of the paper has serious mistakes and the numerical results are quite misleading because such a calculation even with small grids for Jacobi momenta and the angle variables leads to a huge memory of 37.8 PB (petabyte) which cannot even be achieved on present supercomputers.

Citation historyopen in Citation History ↗